UnknownWhat are you doing for Halloween, Kelly?
KellyNew phone, who is this?
UnknownOh, this could be fun.
KellyWhat could?
UnknownMaking you remember who I am.
UnknownTrick or treat? Your choice.
KellyWhat do you mean? Tell me who you are.
UnknownThere’s no way you’ve forgotten me.
KellyOkay then tell me.
UnknownI don’t think so. It’s more fun this way.
KellyFor you, maybe.
UnknownDon’t you like playing games?
Unknown:(
UnknownYou used to…
UnknownAnd you liked to dress up…
Unknown;)
KellyNow THAT’s got my attention!
UnknownI thought it might.
KellySo, we dated?
UnknownNot so fast. There are rules to every game.
UnknownEven fun games.
KellyOkay.
UnknownBoth of us get to ask questions.
KellyBut you already know who I am, so…?
UnknownSure, but it’s been a while.
Unknown(That was a hint, btw).
KellyOkay.
KellyIiiiiinteresting.
UnknownYou’re welcome.
UnknownBoth of us get to ask questions.
KellyYes or no only?
UnknownANY questions.
UnknownAnd we have to tell the truth.
UnknownFor this to work, we can’t lie to each other.
KellyBut how will I know YOU’RE telling the truth?
KellyI don’t even know who this is.
UnknownYou know me.
UnknownI never lie.
KellyYeah right. Everybody lies.
KellyOr HAS lied in their life.
UnknownNot tonight.
UnknownTonight there will be consequences for lying.
Kelly🙄 Let me guess: spankings?
UnknownIs that what you want?
UnknownFor me to make you scream?
UnknownIt’s a perfect night for it.
UnknownAnd it wouldn’t be the first time you screamed for me.
Kelly
UnknownCat got your tongue? lol
KellyThis is so weird.
KellyYou could be anyone.
KellyYou could be David playing a Halloween prank.
UnknownI’m not David.
UnknownBut I promise I can make you forget all about him.
KellyWell, this escalated quickly.
UnknownAre you interested in playing?
KellyI’m…yes. Lol
UnknownGood girl.
UnknownAnd we HAVE to answer each other.
UnknownNo passing or deflecting.
KellyOkay.
UnknownWould you like to ask the first question?
KellyLadies first? Sure. What’s your name?
UnknownNow come on, Kelly.
UnknownDon’t suck the fun out of this by being prosaic.
KellyProsaic…that’s too fancy of a word for David.
UnknownI told you already, I’m not David.
UnknownStop fishing for info and ask your question.
KellyOkay. Um…Did we date?
UnknownWe went out a few times.
KellyBut we weren’t in a relationship?
UnknownThat’s a second question. No cheating.
KellyCheating?
UnknownIt’s my turn.
KellyI thought we were just asking questions as they occurred to us.
UnknownWe are, but I thought of a good one.
KellyOkay. Ask away!
UnknownDo you enjoy swimming?
KellyNope. My turn!
KellyWhat do you look like?
UnknownAverage height. Athletic build. Black hair, blue eyes.
KellyMmm. I’m not mad at any of that!
UnknownThank you. You never had any complaints before.
KellyNow you’re teasing.
KellyCome on, just tell me your name.
KellyPlease?
UnknownYou need to guess.
KellyThis is hard.
UnknownI know. My turn.
UnknownDo you like Halloween?
KellyNo.
KellyI used to, but not anymore.
UnknownInteresting. Here’s another one.
UnknownHave you ever broken someone’s heart?
KellyI don’t think so. I’m usually the dumped rather than the dumper.
UnknownThat’s a lie.
Kelly?
KellyWere we in a relationship?
UnknownYes.
KellyBut you said
Kelly
Unknown‘Relationship’ can mean many things.
KellyThat’s not fair!
UnknownDon’t talk to me about fair.
KellyWow.
KellyDid I do something to you?
UnknownYou did this to yourself by asking the wrong thing.
UnknownAnd it’s MY turn.
KellyYou’re being rude.
UnknownHave you ever known someone who was murdered?
KellyWho is this? I’m seriously asking now.
UnknownAnswer the question.
KellyStop! Tell me who this is.
UnknownAnswer.
KellyYou know what, I don’t think I want to play this game anymore.
UnknownYou’re already playing it.
KellyWas. I quit.
UnknownThere is no quitting.
UnknownLet me be more specific. Have you ever seen a dead body?
KellyYou’re sick. Who the hell is this?!
UnknownI know all your secrets, Kelly.
UnknownDon’t make me tell everyone.
KellyI don’t have any secrets.
UnknownYou said it yourself earlier.
UnknownEveryone lies, or has lied in their life.
KellyThat’s not what I meant.
UnknownI know what you meant.
UnknownI know EVERYTHING.
UnknownAnd if you don’t play with me…
Unknown
Kelly drops her phone and it vibrates with another text. Her fingers tremble as she picks it up.
UnknownI know everything.
KellyWho is that? In the pic?
UnknownDo NOT play stupid right now.
KellyI’m not!
UnknownWe both know exactly who that is.
KellyI don’t!
UnknownL
UnknownI
UnknownA
UnknownR
UnknownPants on fire. A truth about me? I ALWAYS call bluffs, Kelly.
Unknown:)
KellyWhy are you doing this?!
UnknownIt’s not your turn to ask a question.
KellyWHO ARE YOU?!
UnknownI suggest you figure it out.
UnknownAs quickly as possible.